We Built a Streaming Box From Spare Parts and Regret. The Fire Stick Is Cheaper. We Don't Care.
Let's get the accounting out of the way first, because the accounting is brutal.
A Fire Stick 4K: $49.99, frequently $29.99 on sale, arrives tomorrow. An Apple TV: $129, arrives even faster, and it just works. Our DIY streaming box — a Raspberry Pi 5, a case, a power supply, a proper heatsink, and an SD card — came to roughly $73, plus four hours of our lives, plus one evening where the remote simply refused to pair and we briefly considered a career change.
On paper, this project loses. In the workshop, it wins by a landslide. Let us explain.
The Build, Minus the Parts Where We Cried
The recipe is well-worn: a Raspberry Pi 5, a NVMe HAT if you're fancy (we were), and LibreELEC or Kodi as the operating system. Flash the image, boot it, configure the IR receiver, argue with HDMI-CEC, done.
We chose Kodi on LibreELEC because it boots in under ten seconds and turns the Pi into a single-purpose appliance. There's something deeply Finnish about this — a device that does exactly one thing, does it quietly, and doesn't nag you with a home screen full of sponsored content. The Apple TV is a lovely piece of engineering, but it is also a billboard with excellent manners.
The build itself: snap the Pi into the case, mount the heatsink, connect the NVMe, flash the card, boot. Total assembly time, honestly, about 40 minutes. The remaining three hours and twenty minutes were spent on the things no product page mentions: getting the IR remote blaster configured, teaching CEC to stop letting the TV wake the Pi at 3 a.m., and hunting down a codec setting that had our test video playing back like a slideshow of itself.
The Numbers, Honestly
We measured. Of course we measured; we own a kill-a-watt meter and no self-control.
- Fire Stick: ~3W streaming, but it's a sealed box you cannot fix, audit, or meaningfully change.
- Apple TV: ~4-5W, gorgeous, locked garden, $129.
- Our Pi box: ~5.5W streaming, ~2W idle, $73 in parts, infinitely serviceable.
So the Pi draws slightly more power than the Fire Stick. The Fire Stick, however, runs hot enough to warm a small pastry and has roughly the repairability of a river stone. The Pi has a fan curve we control, storage we can swap, and an OS we can rebuild from scratch at 2 a.m. if we break it — which we did, once, on purpose, just to see if we could.
What Buying Never Teaches You
Here's the thing nobody says out loud: the commercial streaming stick is the better product. It's cheaper, smaller, and its remote doesn't need a YAML file to behave. If you're shopping purely on specs and price, buy the Fire Stick and feel zero guilt.
But a product teaches you only its features. A build teaches you systems. After this weekend we understand HDMI-CEC well enough to debug it, understand thermal throttling well enough to tune it, and understand our own living room's network well enough to be slightly horrified by it. No unboxing video imparts that.
There's also the matter of ownership. Our box streams from our own NAS, plays our own ripped CDs, and shows no ads, because there is nothing in it that knows how to show ads. Try asking the Fire Stick to forget that. It won't. It's very committed.
Verdict: A Rational Loss
Final tally: the Fire Stick wins on price, the Apple TV wins on polish, and our Pi box wins on everything that doesn't fit in a spreadsheet — repairability, privacy, the smug glow of knowing exactly what's inside, and the fact that when it eventually dies, we'll fix it with a $15 part instead of a $50 replacement.
Is that rational? Barely. Is it satisfying? Immensely. Some purchases are transactions. This one was an education that happens to also play The Great British Bake Off in 4K.
The Fire Stick is cheaper. We don't care. And somewhere, a Finnish engineer is nodding slowly, which is the highest compliment available.